STUDY ANALYSIS OF INDONESIAN CONSUMER`S BEHAVIOR IN

STUDY ANALYSIS OF INDONESIAN CONSUMER’S BEHAVIOR IN UTILISING
DETERGENT AS MEANS OF WASHING
FINAL PROJECT
By
Manggala Putra Sulistyo
19006062
Undergraduate Program of Management Study
School of Business and Management
Institut Teknologi Bandung
2010
STUDY ANALYSIS OF INDONESIAN CONSUMER’S BEHAVIOR IN UTILISING
DETERGENT AS MEANS OF WASHING
By
MANGGALA PUTRA SULISTYO
ID No: 19006062
A Final Project in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirement for the Degree of Bachelor of Management
Undergraduate Program of Management Study
School of Business and Management
Institut Teknologi Bandung
March 18th, 2010
Approved By
___________________________
DRS. Herry Hudrasyah, MA.
ABSTRACT
Indonesian watery system is experiencing increasing in domestic pollution level for the last decades.
There are more than 60 of total 470 watersheds that placed all around Indonesian is in critical condition.
Majority of the cause are domestic waste such as laundry and other cleaning activity waste. From those
numbers, Java region is become the major contributor for 26 watersheds have been critically damaged.
Further, we could know that is in Jakarta for parameters detergent (MBA), the percentage of wells that
exceed the quality standards in Jakarta by 29% in June 2004 and increased to 46% on the month of
October 2004; and still growing.
The research used exploratory research which consists of literature study, ethnographic approach, focus
group discussion and experts in-depth interview. This research has been designed to see relationship
between the cause and the goal from behavior of consumers in using detergent and explore the idea to
improve those values from the marketing side. For further, this research presents a set of marketing
approach in developing the analyzed solution for increasing consumer’s knowledge level for detergent
utility in order to decrease, or avoid, environmental effect of detergent.
The qualitative analysis show some key variables that affect the behavior of detergent users in Indonesia.
They are product-based experience, knowledge of use, environment awareness, needs, and
communication of each parties.
The research recommends to the stakeholders of this industry, especially producers, government, and any
related parties, to: (1) implemented educational marketing method which could develop the awareness
and perception of consumers for environmental based information that related to the products; (2) redesign the cycle of product to develop further use of its after-use waste and developing its affinity to the
consumers; (3) Developing communication based in green marketing concept with each related parties to
develop line of information for consumers; (4) to develop specification within law and regulatory system
to communicate the forbade or limitation of environmental impact of utilitize detergent product in the
society.
Keywords: consumer behavior, ethnographic, field note, detergent, waste, green marketing.
i
ABSTRAK
Sistem pengairan domestik Indonesia mengalami peningkatan dalam tingkat polusinya pada dekade
terakhir ini. Terdapat lebih dari 60 buah Daerah Aliran Sungai (DAS) dari 470 total DAS di seluruh
Indonesia kini dalam keadaan kritis. Sebagian besar penyebabnya adalah limbah domestik seperti limbah
mencuci dan limbah akibat aktifitas mencuci lainnya. Dari angka-angka tersebut, wilayah Jawa menjadi
kontributor terbesar yaitu sebanyak 26 DAS telah tercemar secara kritis. Lebih lanjut lagi, kita sudah
mengetahui bahwa di Jakarta untuk tingkat detergent (MBA), persentase dari sumur yang telah melewati
standar kualitas di telah mencapai 29% pada bulan Juni 2004 dan meningkat menjadi 46% pada bulan
Oktober 2004; angka ini masih terus meningkat.
Penelitian ini menggunakan metode exploratory research yang terdiri dari studi literatur, pendekatan
ethnographic, focus group discussion, dan wawancara mendalam kepada para ahli. Penelitian ini telah
dirancang untuk melihat hubungan antara sebab dan akibat dalam tingkah laku konsumen dalam
penggunaan deterjen dan menggali ide untuk lebih mengembangkan nila-nilai tersebut dari sisi pasar.
Lebih jauh, penelitian ini mempersembahkan serangkaian pendekatan pasar dalam mengembangkan
solusi yang telah dianalisa untuk meningkatkan tingkat infomrasi konsumen dalam penggunaan deterjen,
untuk mengurangi—atau mencegah—efek samping deterjen pada lingkungan.
Analisa data menunjukkan beberapa variabel kunci yang mempengaruhi tingkat perilaku dari pengguna
deterjen di Indonesia. Variabel-variabel tersebut adalah pengalaman terhadap produk, pengetahuan dalam
penggunaan produk, kesadaran terhadap lingkungan, kebutuhan, dan komunikasi terhadap berbagai pihak.
Penelitian ini merekomendasikan kepada pihak-pihak terkait di industri ini, khusunya produsen,
pemerintah, dan setiap pihak-pihak yang terkait, untuk: (1) menerapkan metode pemasaran yang
mendidik sehingga dapat meningkatkan pemahaman dan persepsi dari pengguna produk untuk informasi
tentang lingkungan yang terkait dengan produk itu sendiri, (2) mendesain ulang siklus produk sehingga
dapat digunakan kembali setelah pemakaian dan penerapannya pada konsumen, (3) mengembangkan
komunikasi berbasis konsep green marketing dengan pihak-pihak yang terkait untuk mengembangkan
jalur informasi kepada konsumen; (4) mengadakan spesifikasi dalam perundang-undangan dan sistem
peraturan untuk mengkomunikasikan pelarangan atau pembatasan dari dampak lingkungan yang
dihasilkan dari penggunaan produk deterjen dalam masyarakat.
Kata kunci: perilaku konsumen, ethnographic, catatan lapangan, deterjen, limbah, green marketing.
i
FOREWORD
Praise Allah the Almighty for His blessings in this final project. This project couldn’t be completed if
Allah didn’t give me strengths for doing this research. I’m glad to offer my greatest gratitude for them
who have supported me and my final project:
1. DRS. Herry Hudrasyah, MA for all his guidance, assistance, knowledge, thought, idea, kindness,
patience, and time in supervising my research. It’s really nice to be supervised by you, Sir.
2. My beloved Sulistyo family, Dipl.Ing. Tony Sulistyo (Papa), Dr. Anita Linda Wijaya Sp.RM
(Mama), Dr. Rigina Nilandrani (Gina), and my twin partner Mahardhika Putra Sulistyo (Dhika),
for the unlimited supports, love, and prayers that always accompany me every moment and
forever. Also my Sarbini and Ramadanus family for their unaccountable supports.
3. All SBM Family:

Lecturers

Tutors

Administration Staffs (Mrs. Ikum, Mr. Yayat, and Mr. Iwan)

Library Staffs

All SBM ’09 Students
4. Dr. Ir. Katharina Oginawati M.S. of Teknik Lingkungan ITB for her help in an enligthment
interview that provide resourceful data. Also to her research which give this research a new
perspective in environmental based technology.
5. The amusing “Geng Maret”: Aditya Pratama, Adityawarman Dwi Putra, Narendro Anindyo,
Agga Diguci, Alessandra Usman, Etgar Equator, Louis Philip, Hasfi Sihite, Pandji Alfi, Anggara
Pradana, Tahta Prawiratama, Nina Shanti which provide amusement time within our last minute
in SBM-ITB. Also writer’s neighbor in Cisitu Lama IX no.21: Muhammad Robby, Ginanjar
Mahar, Jasper Marbun, and others for their 3 years companion.
v
6. Meidiana Adhika for her lovable direct and indirect support from the distances. It is nice to have a
company in doing this research and for its chat that makes me awake more than the coffee effect.
Also, for your resourceful knowledge in law and regulations, it is more than enough in fact.
Thank you.
7. Author’s long-time neighbors in Tamansari Persada Raya, which give various kind of support in
completing this research. Their ideas and aspiration leading to the finish line of this research.
8. And for others that I couldn’t mention one by one.
Finally, the writer realizes that it is not impossible that this final paper still have mistakes in the technical
aspects or in the way the it’ll be serves as final paper. Therefore, author is welcoming for all comments,
supportive-critical statement, and suggestion from the readers.
Bandung, March 2010
Manggala Putra Sulistyo
vi
LIST OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT............................................................................................................................................. i
FOREWORD .......................................................................................................................................... v
LIST OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................................... vii
LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................................ ix
LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................................. xi
LIST OF IMAGES ............................................................................................................................... xiii
LIST OF APPENDIXES ...................................................................................................................... xiv
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 1
1.1. Research Background .................................................................................................................... 1
1.2. Problem Statement......................................................................................................................... 3
1.3. Research Questions ....................................................................................................................... 3
1.4. Objectives ..................................................................................................................................... 3
1.5. Research Limitation ....................................................................................................................... 4
1.6. Research Methodology .................................................................................................................. 4
1.7. Writing Structure ........................................................................................................................... 6
CHAPTER 2 THEORETICAL FOUNDATION ...................................................................................... 7
2.1. Consumer Behavior ....................................................................................................................... 7
2.1.1. Perception .............................................................................................................................. 7
2.1.2. Purchase Decision .................................................................................................................. 8
2.1.3. Brand Loyalty ...................................................................................................................... 10
2.2. Green Marketing.......................................................................................................................... 10
2.3. Eco-Design.................................................................................................................................. 13
2.4. Ethnographic Research ................................................................................................................ 14
CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY........................................................................................................... 17
3.1. Focus Group Discussion .............................................................................................................. 18
3.2. Expert In-Depth Interview ........................................................................................................... 19
3.3. Ethnographic Approach ............................................................................................................... 20
CHAPTER 4 QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS ........................................................................................... 21
4.1. Focus Group Discussion .............................................................................................................. 21
4.1.1. Basic Perception and Loyalty ............................................................................................... 22
4.1.2. Knowledge and Awareness .................................................................................................. 24
4.1.3. Post-Purchase Behavior........................................................................................................ 27
4.1.4. Resume of Focus Group Discussion ..................................................................................... 28
4.2. Ethnographic Approach ............................................................................................................... 31
4.2.1. Mrs. Yanti ............................................................................................................................ 31
4.2.2. Mrs. Mamiek ....................................................................................................................... 33
4.2.3. Mrs. Mira ............................................................................................................................. 35
4.2.4. Mrs. Imas ............................................................................................................................. 36
4.2.5. Domain Analysis.................................................................................................................. 37
4.3. In-Depth Interview ...................................................................................................................... 43
CHAPTER 5 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION ................................................................. 49
5.1. Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 49
5.2. Recommendation ......................................................................................................................... 50
REFERENCES...................................................................................................................................... 51
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.1
Research Design Outline ..................................................................................................... 5
Figure 2.1
Perceptual Process .............................................................................................................. 7
Figure 2.2
Simple model of consumer decision making ........................................................................ 9
Figure 2.3
John Grant’s Green Marketing Grid .................................................................................. 12
Figure 2.4
Ethnographic Method ........................................................................................................ 14
Figure 2.5
Domain Analysis .............................................................................................................. 15
Figure 3.1
Research Design ............................................................................................................... 17
Figure 3.2
Levels of Education Approach .......................................................................................... 18
Figure 4.1
Distribution of Participants ............................................................................................... 21
Figure 4.2
Cause-Effect Relation (1) .................................................................................................. 38
Figure 4.3
Cause-Effect Relation (2) .................................................................................................. 38
Figure 4.4
Location for Action Relation ............................................................................................. 39
Figure 4.5
Function Relation.............................................................................................................. 40
Figure 4.6
Means-End Relation (1) .................................................................................................... 41
Figure 4.7
Means-End Relation (2) .................................................................................................... 41
Figure 4.8
Sequence Relation............................................................................................................. 42
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2.1
New Green Marketing Paradigms ....................................................................................... 10
Table 4.1
Focus Group Discussion Resumed ...................................................................................... 28
LIST OF IMAGES
Image 4.1
Specification of Rinso Anti Noda ...................................................................................... 24
Image 4.2
Notes in product packaging .............................................................................................. 30
Image 4.3
Example of water remediation method that using activated carbon ..................................... 47
LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX A
APPENDIX B
INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
SPECIFICATION OF RINSO ANTI NODA