Gaining Experience Using the Classification Method: A Job Evaluation Exercise Vicki Fairbanks Taylor Shippensburg University ABSTRACT This exercise enables students to practice the classification method of job evaluation. Students are assigned to a “classification committee” and are given five position descriptions to classify using The American Society of Civil Engineers’ Job Grading Standards. After individually classifying the positions, members of the classification committee work together to arrive at a consensus on the classification of each position. Following classification, the committee establishes a salary range for the job structure using internet-based resources. This exercise is appropriate for graduate and undergraduate students studying human resource management and compensation management. A brief review of job evaluation and the classification method of job evaluation is provided along with a discussion of exercise, teaching notes and exercise handouts. Key Words: compensation, job evaluation, classification method, human resources management, experiential exercise INTRODUCTION TO JOB EVALUATION Job evaluation is the process of systematically determining the value or relative worth of jobs in an organization. Because the results of the job evaluation process are used in the establishment of pay rates, job evaluation has the potential to significantly influence employee performance and fairness perceptions (Milkovich, Newman, & Gerhart, 2011). There are various job evaluation methods; however, ranking, the point method, and job classification are the most commonly employed (Milkovich, et. al., 2011). The ranking method orders positions from highest to lowest according to the relative difficulty or importance of each job. The point factor method calculates job worth by assigning a point value to jobs based on the degree to which certain compensable factors are present in the position (e.g., skill, responsibility, effort, and working conditions). Job classification is considered a non-quantitative job evaluation method where jobs are compared to standardized position descriptions and assigned to a specific grade or level within the classification (WorldatWork, 2007). The standardized position descriptions used in the job classification process can be developed internally by the organization or external standards can be adopted. For example, professional organizations, such as the American Society of Civil Engineers, Journal of Human Resources Education 32 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 publish job classification standards which are used by organizations when classifying civil engineering jobs. Another example of a job classification system is the one used by the U.S. federal government. The General Schedule classification system contains 15 levels (GS–1 to GS–15) covering professional, technical, administrative, clerical, and other occupations. The basic steps in the job classification method include the following: (1) conduct a job analysis and write a position description; (2) compare the job’s content to a generic position description; and (3) assign the job to the appropriate classification level or grade. The result of the job evaluation process is a job structure which shows the hierarchy of jobs within an organization. Market data is then secured for a limited number of jobs in the hierarchy and is used to develop the final pay structure. In an attempt to help students gain experience in the classification method of job evaluation, a job classification exercise was developed. Students were provided job grading guidelines (generic position descriptions) published by the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) which outline the knowledge, skills, and responsibilities associated with engineers in seven different grades, from engineer-in-training to an executive-level position. Students were also given positions descriptions for five different engineering positions downloaded from an internet-based engineering job board and asked to classify the positions using the ASCE Guidelines for Engineering Grades. After classifying the positions individually, students worked together as a classification committee to reach a consensus on the classifications of each position description and to create a job structure. The classification committee then used internet-based resources (O*Net Online and Glassdoor.com) to establish a pay structure with pay rates for each of the engineering jobs. At the conclusion of the exercise, students presented their results in class and were shown how the same jobs had been classified by subject matter experts (SMEs) from a local civil engineering firm. Students then participated in an instructor-led discussion concerning the job evaluation process, the classification method of job evaluation, and the process of establishing a pay structure that balances internal alignment with eternal competitiveness. An overview of the exercise, as well as instructions for conducting and debriefing the exercise, follow. OVERVIEW OF THE EXERCISE This exercise was developed for use in a face-to-face undergraduate compensation class. Other potential uses for the exercise include undergraduate and graduate courses in human resource management or a graduate course in compensation. This exercise could also be adopted in an online course with group work and discussions taking place through the discussion board feature of a course management system such as Blackboard© or Desire2Learn©. By participating in this exercise, participants will (1) gain experience in evaluating jobs using the job classification method; (2) synthesize multiple concepts on the topic of job evaluation including the basis for valuing work in organizations, the social and political process of job evaluation, issues of reliability, and linking job evaluation results to the external market Journal of Human Resources Education 33 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 rates for jobs; and (3) reflect upon the strengths and weaknesses of the classification method of job evaluation. The exercise can be completed in one hour and fifteen minutes provided students have classified the positions individually prior to class. The exercise was successfully conducted in a class of 40 students working in groups of five students each. FACILITATING THE EXERCISE Prior to the exercise, students should be assigned readings on the topic of job evaluation. Both human resource management textbooks and compensation textbooks frequently contain sufficient detail on the job evaluation process and the various job evaluation methods typically employed by organizations (see Appendix A for a suggested reading list). The instructor should provide students with the assignment instructions which includes the hyperlink to the ASCE Guidelines for Engineering Grades and the five position descriptions (see Appendix B). Preceding the in-class group exercise, students should be instructed to classify each of the five positions using the ASCE guidelines and to bring their classification decisions and notes justifying their classifications to class. On the day of class, place students in assigned groups. Each group will need to have internet access to find salary data for a benchmark job. Explain to students that each group is working as a classification committee charged with classifying and pricing the five new positions. Tell students they will have 25 minutes to reach a consensus on the classification of each position. After reaching a consensus, instruct students to find salary data for a benchmark job in the job structure using the following websites: O*Net online or Glassdoor.com. If necessary, review the concept of a benchmark job as one that would be common across different employers and include a sizable number of employees or tell students to use “civil engineer” as the benchmark job for the job structure. Allow the groups 10 minutes to locate salary data for the benchmark position and then remind the groups to follow the assignment instructions and price the remaining jobs in the job structure. While students are interacting, visit each group to observe the consensus-reaching process and take notes on any impasses or issues of conflict among team members. The instructor should also be available to answer questions on locating salary information using the assigned websites. After groups have located the salary information and priced the remaining jobs, have a representative from each group write their group’s job structure for the five positions (i.e., list the five jobs in order from most valuable to least valuable) and the pay rate for each position on the classroom white/chalk board or flip chart paper. After all of the groups have shared their job structures and pay rates, provide a copy of the job structure developed by the SMEs from the engineering firm (Appendix C). Use the remainder of the class time (approximately 25 minutes) to facilitate a discussion focused on the following: (1) the challenges experienced in assessing job content; (2) the reliability of the job classification method; (3) the social/political nature of job evaluation; and (4) the purpose of linking the internal job structure to external market data. Conclude the discussion with a brief summary of the advantages and disadvantages of the classification method of job evaluation. Journal of Human Resources Education 34 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 75-Minute Learning Module • • • • • • • Distribute the assignment which includes the job descriptions and a link to the ASCE guidelines for engineering grades Instruct students to complete their individual job evaluations prior to the scheduled class exercise and discussion. On the day of class exercise, divide students into groups of five and instruct groups to reach a consensus on the classification of the five jobs (25 minutes). Instruct students to determine a pay rate for a benchmark job using O*Net online and Glassdoor.com. Have students price the remaining jobs in the job structure based off of the benchmark rate (20 minutes). Have students create and post the group’s job structure for the five positions along with the pay rate (5 minutes) Post the SMEs job structure Facilitate a discussion on the topics of the job classification method of job evaluation and market pricing of jobs (25 minutes). Discussion Questions After the students have posted their results, begin by sharing with the class how the positions were classified by SMEs working for a civil engineering firm. Have students determine how closely each group’s job evaluations aligned with the opinions of the SMEs. Begin the discussion by asking: How did you approach the job classification process? Numerous approaches to job classification may arise, including a focus on the job duties, a focus on the job specifications, or a combination of the two. It is important to stress the weighing of job duties over job specifications. Job specifications should specify the minimum knowledge, skills, abilities, and other qualities necessary to successfully complete the job duties. In this exercise, the job duties of the Roadway/Highway Engineer are that of a Grade II Engineer, while the job specifications are that of a Grade III Engineer. The inconsistency between job duties and job specifications for the Roadway/Highway Engineer provide an opportunity to stress the role job content plays in the classification method of job evaluation. Instructors may want to introduce students to the following mantra, “evaluate the job and not the job holder.” To introduce students to the social/political nature of the job evaluation process ask the following follow-up questions: Why might the job responsibilities and job specifications for the position not be aligned? Supervisors are often responsible for writing the position descriptions that are reviewed by the job classification committee. Job descriptions contain a list of job responsibilities as well as the job specifications or the knowledge, skills, abilities and other qualifications necessary to successfully complete the job. Sometimes job specifications are inflated based on the previous incumbent’s qualifications, the supervisor’s desire to increase the salary for the position to enhance recruiting efforts, confusion over preferred vs. minimum qualifications, the desire to reward an incumbent by reclassifying the job to a higher grade, or some combination of these factors. Research shows that powerful managers can influence the decisions of classification committees (Welbourne & Trevor, 2000); therefore classification committees must be able to justify their decisions and operate with the support of upper management if the job evaluation system is to result in non-discriminatory, equitable pay Journal of Human Resources Education 35 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 differentials among jobs. The importance of having managerial and non-managerial personnel familiar with the jobs being classified should also be stressed. In addition to the social and political nature of the job evaluation process, the reliability of the job classification method needs to be discussed. Differences in the job structures among groups or between the SMEs’ classification decisions and the groups’ job structures provides an opportunity to discuss the reliability of job evaluations. Ask the following question: Why might two classification committees using the same standards, classify the same job differently? The job classification method is relatively easy to administer and implement once job classifications have been established and generic job descriptions have been developed; however, the job descriptions may be too broad to be useful (Milkovich, et al., 2011). Some jobs may have to be forced to fit into a grade, and, in other instances, jobs may seem to fit into more than one grade/level. Another possible explanation for inconsistent results might be a lack of familiarity with the classification or job family. Again, having individuals on the committee who are familiar with the jobs being classified, and who represent different departments in the organization, is critical. In addition, the classification decisions need to be transparent and subject to review to ensure consistency in the classification of jobs. Then, turn the discussion to the role market data plays in developing the final pay structure by asking: What makes one job more valuable than another? Job content is one obvious answer. The ASCE Guidelines outline the knowledge, skills, and responsibilities associated with each engineering grade. Typically, compensation and benefits increase with higher grades; however, there are many other variables that play a role in pricing a job. Ask a follow-up question: What factors outside of the job content may influence the value of a job? Answers may include the market price for jobs, the local demand and supply of labor, the cost of living in the area in which the job is located, job conditions, how critical the job is to the business, or how powerful the department is in which the job is located. Finally, the instructor can ask: What problems might result from using market data alone to determine an organization’s job structure? According to a 2012 WorldatWork survey of approximately 1,000 members, market pricing was the most frequently listed “method” of job evaluation. Under market pricing, the value of a job is determined strictly by the “going rate” for labor. Using market pricing alone can result in pay inequities and variability. Perceived pay inequities can lead to pay dissatisfaction which, in turn, can result in decreased organizational commitment and increased turnover intentions (Vandenberghe & Tremblay, 2008). In addition, the use of market data alone to determine job values may perpetuate existing wage inequities for females and minorities, thus leaving an organization vulnerable to claims of discrimination (Milkovich, et al., 2011). Discussion Summary There is no perfect job evaluation system and research shows that different job evaluation methods generate different pay structures (Madigan & Hoover, 1986). Job classification is a non-quantitative, whole-job method of conducting job evaluations. The classification method is used in the U.S. federal government and in private and public organizations. Challenges include the development of classifications and writing standardized position descriptions representing the Journal of Human Resources Education 36 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 various levels within the classification; however, existing standards for many occupational groups exist which can be adopted. The classification method is relatively easy to understand and administer, but it can be impractical for organizations with widely diverse job families. In addition, system integrity can be compromised if job descriptions are written based on classification standards versus the actual work to be performed. Human resource generalists and compensation specialists are frequently involved in the job evaluation process. HR professionals should become familiar with the various methods of job evaluation and should be able to assist in the development and administration of a job evaluation plan which supports the organization’s objectives and values. _______________ Vicki Fairbanks Taylor, Ph.D., is an associate professor of management in the John L. Grove College of Business, Shippensburg University. She earned her doctorate from Temple University and teaches a variety of courses in human resource management. Her research interests include organizational culture, interviewing, employee discipline, and management education. Contact: [email protected]. REFERENCES Madigan, R., & Hoover, D. (1986). Effects of alternative job evaluation methods on decisions involving pay equity. Academy of Management Journal, 29 (1), 84-100. Milkovich, G., Newman, J., & Gerhart, J. (2011). Compensation (10th ed.). Boston: McGrawHill Irwin. Vandenberghe, C., & Tremblay, M. (2008). The role of pay satisfaction and organizational commitment in turnover intentions: A two-sample study. Journal of Business Psychology, 22 (3), 275–286. Welbourne, T., & Trevor, C. (2000). The roles of departmental and position power in job evaluation. Academy of Management Journal, 43 (4), 761-771. WorldatWork. (2007). The WorldatWork handbook of compensation, benefits & total rewards: A comprehensive guide for HR professionals. Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons. Journal of Human Resources Education 37 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Appendix A Recommended Reading List on Job Evaluation 1. Dessler, Gary (2013). Fundamental of Human Resource Management, 3rd Ed. Pearson/Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. 2. Heneman, R. L. (2003). Job and Work Evaluation: A Literature Review. Public Personnel Management, 32 (1), 47. 3. Martocchio, J. J. (2015). Strategic Compensation, 8th Ed. Pearson/Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. 4. Milkovich, George T., Newman, Jerry M., & Gerhart, Jerry (2011). Compensation, 10th Ed., McGraw-Hill Irwin. 5. Office of Personnel Management, General Schedule Classification and Pay (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/pay-leave/pay-systems/general-schedule/ 6. The Bureau of National Affairs, Compensation and Benefits Library (n.d.). Retrieved from http://hr.bna.com/hrrc/#/cb 7. WorldatWork (2007). The WorldatWork Handbook of Compensation, Benefits, & Total Rewards: A Comprehensive Guide for HR Professionals. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. Journal of Human Resources Education 38 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Appendix B Job Evaluation at Alpha Engineering (Student Handout) Objective This exercise has been developed to give you experience in the job evaluation process, using the classification method. Overview of the Assignment Working as members of a job evaluation committee of Alpha Engineering, your task is to evaluate five civil engineering jobs using the ASCE Guidelines for Engineering Grades. The five jobs are bridge engineer, project engineer, construction engineer, civil engineer, and roadway/highway engineer. The position descriptions can be found on the pages following the assignment instructions. Use the following hyperlink to locate the ASCE Guideline for Engineering Grades: http://www.asce.org/Leadership-Resources/Leadership-Tools-andResources/Guidelines-for-Engineering-Grades/ Instructions 1. Working individually, each member of the compensation committee determines the classification level of each position using the ASCE Guideline for Engineering Grades. 2. Share your decisions with your group. As a group, arrive at a consensus for the classification of each position. Make sure to record the reasons for your classification. 3. Establish pay rates for the all of the jobs in the job structure by (a) identifying a benchmark job for the job structure, (b) determining a competitive pay rate for the benchmark job using O*Net Online <http://www.onetonline.org/> and Glassdoor.com <http://www.glassdoor.com/index.htm>, and (c) pricing the remaining jobs in the job structure based on the rate for the benchmark job. 4. Upon completion of the job evaluation exercise, present your job structure and pay structure to the class. Journal of Human Resources Education 39 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Bridge Engineer Job Description Job Summary: The Bridge Engineer will manage tasks and projects for highway transportation structures, including bridges and ancillary structures Job Duties: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Oversee the design structural components of box culverts, retaining walls and related structures Develop Contract Bid Packages of plans, specifications and engineer's construction cost estimate Develop details of bridge components for contracts drawings Understand and develop construction sequencing Perform Load Ratings Oversee and perform bridge inspections as a Team Leader Review bridge inspection reports Participate in project meetings and write minutes of such meetings Some client contact that will be handled in a professional manner Track Project Budget and costs Strong understanding of Project Scope and identifying work that is outside of project scope Develop man-hour estimates Understand the requirements of other disciplines and how they impact the project Day-to-day management of projects for the bridge department, including structural design and analysis and development of contract documents. Supervise and mentor less experienced engineers. Supervise CADD Technicians developing plan sets Coordinate and work with engineers in other disciplines Be able to communicate via spoken and written word with other technical and nontechnical personnel. Job Requirements: • • • • Bachelor's Degree in Civil Engineering. Master's in Civil Engineering preferred. PE 12+ years of Bridge Engineering experience NBIS two-week Bridge Inspector's Course and Fracture Critical Member Inspection Course a plus. Journal of Human Resources Education 40 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Project Engineer Job Description Job Summary: As a fully competent Registered Professional Engineer, performs work involving the application of all conventional aspects of civil engineering to the functional area of the assignment. Job Duties: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Exercises judgment in the independent evaluation, selection and substantial adaptation and modification of standard techniques, procedures, and criteria. Responsible for applying intensive and diversified knowledge of civil engineering principles and practices in broad areas. Includes technical direction over a group of civil engineers and/or functions as a technical specialist, formulating and developing advanced civil engineering concepts. Coordinates technical and administrative activities with those of other disciplines and other departments in the company participating in a project. Markets the firm’s capabilities within the civil engineering specialty to establish new clients and enhance relationships with existing clients. Prepares proposals for potential projects. Participates in the selection of design teams and sub-consultants and in the negotiations of fees and subcontractors. Conducts constructability reviews or assists in the design/planning/review of other civil engineering projects not assigned to the incumbent. Supervises the design and ongoing progress of a project, including the coordination of the project with City, State, and County officials, and other outside agencies. Resolves a variety of complex problems, (i.e. conflicting design requirements, unsuitability of conventional materials, difficult coordination requirements). Serves as a liaison between clients and agencies, subcontractors, and design teams. Reviews plans and prepares or reviews technical specifications, contract documents, and estimates. Participates in contract bidding and administration; observes project action on site. Supervises the work of less experienced engineers and/or technical support personnel assigned to the project (not an on-going substantial job component). May be required to complete safety training courses relative to engineering project environments (i.e. fall protection, confined space entry, CPR/first aid, electrical safety, personal protective equipment, OSHA safety, or hazard communication). Travel may be required to attend meetings, project sites, or other business-related functions as part of your job duties. When a company vehicle is unavailable, your personal vehicle shall be utilized. Job Requirements: • • • • Bachelor of Science Degree in Civil Engineering is required; Master of Science Degree in Civil Engineering is a plus. Registration as a Professional Engineer Minimum of five years of progressive work experience within the civil engineering field. Journal of Human Resources Education 41 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Construction Engineer Job Description Job Summary: Perform construction engineering and management duties for land development and municipal projects, focused on water and wastewater treatment facilities. Job Duties: • • • • • • • • • Provide overall administrative and technical direction for land development projects. Oversee total construction management to ensure project is constructed in accordance with design, budget and schedule. Includes interfacing with client representatives, engineers, vendors, subcontractors, etc. Plan, coordinate and/or supervise field activities of field personnel on assigned project(s). Maintain official project log and documentation files. Provide direction to planning, scheduling, and engineering functions as required. Responsible for obtaining signatures for contracts, processing pay estimates and change orders, coordinating inspections and pre-construction meetings. Attend various bid openings and district meetings. Prepare bid tabulations and maintain files for bond issues. Successful candidates will apply good organizational skills and take charge of overall coordination of preparing and reviewing contracts. Job Requirements: • • • • • • • • Bachelors of Science with an emphasis in Civil Engineering Registered Texas Professional Engineer At least 5 years of progressive experience in a Construction Management role At least 5 years of experience with water, wastewater treatment plant expansions, underground utilities, paving projects, ground storage tanks, elevated tanks, water wells, and sewer rehabilitation. Thorough knowledge of all aspects of construction (technology, equipment, methods, procedures and standards) Familiar with subdivision grading, streets, sewage, storm drains, and public works excellent oral and written communication skills Microsoft Office and scheduling software experience Journal of Human Resources Education 42 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Civil Engineer Job Description Job Summary: Position involves designing roadways, site/grading plans, sanitary sewer, storm sewers and waterlines under the supervision of project manager. Job Duties: • • • • • • • • Preparing construction plans and specifications. Coordinating with utility companies, permitting agencies and supervisory staff. Preparing and reviewing storm drainage reports. Reviewing construction plans for technical and grammatical accuracy Preparing accurate summaries of quantities Estimating construction costs Performing field investigations Completing related duties as assigned Job Requirements: • • • • • Civil engineering degree from an accredited university Ability to work well with others in a team environment. intrinsically motivated to meet deadlines and budgets Possess the ability to clearly communicate his/her design intentions to design and drafting technicians. Requires proficiency with Microsoft office applications and AutoCAD Civil 3D. Hydrologic and hydraulic modeling, GIS, construction administration and traffic engineering capabilities are also desirable. Journal of Human Resources Education 43 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Roadway/Highway Engineer Job Description Job Summary: primary focus is to serve in a technical role, under the direction of a Project Manager, on the engineering development of urban and rural highway/roadway projects. Job Duties: • • • • • • Oversee the work of CAD Designers and possibly other EITs, Prepare detailed engineering designs for roadway and highway projects including urban and rural highway interchanges, intersection design, traffic management, transportation planning, and site planning, Preparation of concept alignments, geometrical layout and CAD base alignment plans, Complete drainage and storm water management calculations. Analyze site feasibility to final design and through the construction phase. Coordination of survey, grading, drainage and utilities and layout of various site items Requirements: • • • • • Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineer and PE required 10 years highway design experience Demonstrated hands-on experience using Microstation and either Inroads or GeoPak MS Office knowledge required. Excellent communication and organizational skills required. Journal of Human Resources Education 44 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014 Appendix C (Instructor Resource) Subject Matter Experts’ Opinions Job Title Civil Engineer Roadway/Highway Engineer Construction Engineer Bridge Engineer Project Engineer Classification based on Job Duties Grade I Grade II Grade IV Grade IV Grade V Classification based on Job Specifications Grade I Grade III Grade IV Grade IV or Grade V Grade III Journal of Human Resources Education 45 Vol. 8, No. 2/3, Spring/Summer 2014